As in my last thread I will be giving you four screenshots each of both Blood Gulch from Halo CE and Hemmorage from Halo: Reach. Enjoy!
vs.
^Side view of red base^
vs.
^Front view of blue base^
vs.
^Cave view of blue base^
vs.
^A view of the cliff^
Also, tell me which other maps from Halo CE or Halo 2 you want to be compared to remakes on Halo 3 and Halo: Reach.

You can't compare a map from two separate games which have both got different mechanics and engines... And there is really no purpose or point in this...

This type of thread is dumb, and you should feel dumb.

I don't get the point of this...

Haemorrhage is a remake of bloodgulch so those similarities are kinda expected.
Edited by Megaguirus on Oct 9, 2011 at 06:51 AM

The point is I wanna show how much Halo has changed from Halo CE to Halo: Reach.

There's nothing wrong with that.

Yeah... I still don't get it. Won't people just google images if they wanted to see the change?

Proves that hemorrage is barely anything like BG.

I like this thread, thanks for posting pics for me to look at OP.
And free too :)

I don't see why people are complaining, it's neat to have a side by side comparison.

Also, while I'm here, I just remembered I've been working on Hemorage to make it behave like Blood Gulch.. Does anybody know of any Good pre-configured custom gametypes that would give me similar gameplay to CE? (Indestructable vehicles, no bloom, ect.) CTF would be preferred. That would save me a bit of work in testing the map.
Edited by DieHard Bob on Oct 10, 2011 at 03:46 AM

I could probably do that. Already got the Zero Bloom gametype, just gotta set the vehicles to invunerable, melee to 75% etc...
What's your gamertag?

Wha's your favorite map from the ones that are being remade? Mine is battle creek. I am sad that they didn't remake Sidewinder :/

You know, I don't really know what it is, but I always find that I have a lot more fun playing Hemorrhage than I do playing Blood Gulch on CE, even though they're so similar. I actually look forward to playing Hemorrhage, while I groan every time I see a solid page of dedicated BG servers.
Edited by Kal on Oct 11, 2011 at 02:12 PM

Same. Teh problem with all of the bloodgulch servers is they never have any really interesting gameplay, whiel Hemorrage has lots. But they are both as good, in my opinion.

Those comparsions are really useful to me, I'd like to have more threads like this.

They did, it's called Paradiso

Hey, Sorry for the late reply. My gamertag is the same as my name one here, DieHard Bob.

The only resemblance between those maps I noticed is the forerunner passage in the lower part of the mountain. Wouldn't have even thought it was supposed to be sidewinder inspired.

Not even close

Most people consider Avalanche from Halo 3 to be Sidewinder's successor.

Map packs... Why can't they be free?!

It's very cool to see how much technology has improved since halo 1. I'm personally interested in games because it visually represents computing hardware advancements. Back when halo 1 was released, the hardware didn't exist to render the detail we see in Reach and most modern games. I find it amazing what can be achieved in just over a decade. I could go on and on about moore's law and all that, but the images speak for themselves. Nice comparisons.

Don't blame you, similarities are vague but both are u shaped (although Paradiso has the back path), both have a underground tunnel and both have platforms connected by teleporters. Its not entirely a remake but they are almost roughly vaguely similar. (I've not played the map until now, I just got the idea it's a remake from Halowiki)

Well Paradiso doesn't even have the feel of sidewinder. To me at least.

We need Sidewinder anyway. Sad that we will never get it.