Ton projet est très sympathique en règle générale, et très intéressant sur pas mal de points. :)

Cependant, reprendre une "campagne" sur "l'avant reach" est pour moi inutile. Pourquoi ? Alors tout simplement, le jeu halo reach étant un flaupe total (hormis graphiquement parlant), ne représente absolument pas la guerre qui a fait rage sur la planète reach telle qu'elle est décrite dans les livres, la fin est médiocre et pas peaufinée. Alors maintenant se lancer dans l'avant reach ? Çà serait complètement absurde, il faut savoir qu'a part quelques escarmouches ici et la avec les covenants, les "conflits" "avant reach" n'étaient pas fréquents, on peu même dire presque inexistants.

Donc pour résumer, utiliser le terme "avant reach" n'est pas forcément un bon choix, peut être pourrais tu te lancer dans un autre choix de scénario, peut être un conflit en même temps que la guerre de reach, ou pourquoi pas pendant la fuite des dernières forces militaires présentes sur zone :) Franchement, faire quelques chose avant les évènement d'halo reach est inutile je pense.

That's a little harsh, but I do agree with the discrepencies between the novels, games and tv.
Edited by Super Flanker on Dec 29, 2016 at 03:18 PM

I'll try to translate it for you guys.

Your project is very interesting in some points.

However, make a new story based on "before reach" isn't a good idea for me. Why ? Because, to do simple, halo reach game is sloppy (except graphics), it doesn't represent the war that raged on the planet reach as described in the books, the end is mediocre and not finalised. So now you want to make a scenario "before reach"? It would be completely absurd, it is necessary to know that apart from some skirmishes here and there with the covenants, the "conflicts" before reach invasion "were not frequent, almost nonexistent.

So to summarize, use the term "before reach" is not necessarily a good choice, maybe you could launch yourself in another scenario choice, maybe in a conflict at the same time as the invasion of reach, or why not during the retreat military forces present on the planet. Doing something before the halo event reach is useless I think.

I don't know if it's better or not for you english/americans, soo that's all :)

Harvest was before reach. Mb do something with that?

Yes. Harvest is a pretty good idea :)

My idea was to recreate the episode of Thom's death, and this episode can be ended with a recreated cinematic of the arrival of Noble 6 and a sentence "And after, you already know that it's going to take place..."


It's so badass !

For the idea of harvest, why not but, we already have it in Halo WARS...

And Halo REACH is an excellent game for me, yes it don't follow the books, but it's not a bad episode ! I love the story, the OST, caracters...

It's just an idea, I already have a demo of what I can do with REACH's melody.

Isn't that just a re-tread of Halo: Reach's tag line from the advertising?
"From the beginning you know the end..."

Huh... I think yes, but ... yes. okay.